Friday, March 4, 2011

Muriel Award: Best Actor

This race ended up being a lot closer than I expected. A surprise to me - I did not see the support for the second-place finisher being as strong as it was. This is why I don't do prognostication.

Third place:



Tahar Rahim, A Prophet [90 points / 14 votes]

Second place:



Edgar Ramirez, Carlos [135/20]

And your winner...





Jesse Eisenberg, The Social Network [149/24]

"When people talk about The Social Network, the discussion tends to exclusively gravitate around three egomaniacs: director David Fincher, screenwriter Aaron Sorkin and subject Mark Zuckerberg (as well-liked as the score may be, Trent Reznor is generally just a tangental figure in the discourse about the film). It's widely held that the film belongs primarily to these men and with good reason: these men provided the film with its blueprint for success. But it’s The Social Network’s cast that gives the film its bite, and no actor is more crucial to its success than Jesse Eisenberg.

The triumph of Eisenberg’s Zuckerberg, the spite-fueled, OCD-addled, vengeful nerd par excellence, is partly his effortless skill at escaping the corner into which his previous roles had painted him. Until that point, the twee man-boy rivalry that he shared with Michael Cera was largely the pinhole-narrow lens through which people talked about Eisenberg’s career. After The Social Network, it became almost impossible to reconcile the difference between the Eisenberg in dreck like Zombieland and the one dishing out Sorkin’s proudly barbed nouveau-screwball dialogue.

But the real reason why Eisenberg’s performance stands tall amongst a year full of remarkable performances by actors playing raging narcissists is the core of all-consuming rage that fuels it. His unabating ferocity and abject refusal to cede anyone a single point about his character flaws is more than just commanding -- it's dizzyingly accomplished.

Eisenberg is so good that Fincher -- yes, the guy that made Zodiac -- has to keep up with the hyper-self-conscious way he comports himself, specifically his volcanic impatience and the giddy imperiousness. Fincher’s mile-a-minute editing is nothing if not a reflection of Zuckerberg’s busy, analytical gaze, but without Eisenberg’s piercing performance, no amount of ostentatious (but fittingly hyper-caffeinated) cut-cut-cutting would make the film worthwhile. Eisenberg’s performance is The Social Network's engine: Sorkin’s dialogue and Fincher’s meticulous pacing is only as charming as he is." - Simon Abrams

See the full results.

No comments:

Post a Comment