Well folks, it’s nothing but biggies from here on out. We’ll begin today with Best Screenplay, followed over the next several days with awards for Best Documentary, Director, Lead Actor and Actress, and the celebrated Best Film Countdown. And naturally, there will be plenty of fun side business that has helped to make the Muriels something vaguely approximating famous. So stay tuned!
Third place:
The Lobster (Efthimis Filippou and Yorgos Lanthimos) [99 points / 15 votes]
Second place:
Moonlight (Barry Jenkins and Tarell Alvin McCraney) [122 points / 18 votes]
And the Muriel goes to…
Manchester By The Sea (Kenneth Lonergan) [148 points / 22 votes]
“Kenneth Lonergan's three films as writer/director can come across as deceptively sloppy during initial viewings. As if they are bursting at the seams. Even though his background as a playwright ensures that the narrative structure is sound, with each scene carefully building on the last and leading to the next. His plots are really quite simple. His characters are not. As with the films of Arnaud Desplechin and Mike Leigh, Lonergan's worlds are inhabited by such authentic personalities it's a bit overwhelming meeting them all for the first time. During a discussion last fall at the Lincoln Center, Kenneth Lonergan made an offhand remark that explains his approach to character: ‘We all walk into the room carrying something.’
“Even characters with little screen time carry something. In Manchester by the Sea, Otto - the drummer in Patrick Chandler's band - has about five lines split between two scenes. We learn nothing about Otto's biography, just his character as he responds to accusations of going too fast or too slow. Lonergan's direction gives Otto additional weight, providing an extended one-shot of the aggrieved drummer. Otto has nothing to do with Patrick's process of grieving for his recently deceased father. But the attention gives a moment of humanity to a guy trying to keep the beat with other amateur musicians, absorbing the blame for any mistake.
“One mistake during the filming of Manchester resulted in one of the film's most effective moments, the EMS struggling to lift a gurney into an ambulance after a fire. The gurney scene is a distillation of what may be Manchester's greatest strengths, and the reason it has resonated so deeply: the script's recognition of humor's role in tragedy. How when events are completely out of our control and the pain becomes unbearable, humor allows us to take a bit of control back and provide a momentary relief. Lonergan explicitly introduces the tragedy/humor motif in the first flashback when Joe Chandler, Patrick's father, is diagnosed with congestive heart failure. Joe and his brother Lee, the film's antihero, immediately start making jokes about the diagnosis. Joe's wife can't take it and berates them for any attempt at levity, confused she says ‘I do not see where the humor lies in this situation.’ Her inability to process grief creates a parallel with Lee's own struggles, while her strident reaction gives the audience permission to laugh despite the severity of the film's events. At least I thought it did, but when I giggled at the gurney, the glare from the person sitting next to me suggested they most certainly did not see the humor in the situation.” ~ Kevin Cecil



No comments:
Post a Comment