“In Roy Chanslor’s novel Johnny Guitar, the character Vienna, is introduced as a ‘fine bold woman in black pants and a red silk shirt who...rode like a man with the Longergan bunch.’ Chanslor dedicated the novel to Joan Crawford, which may have helped lead her to shepherd the film adaptation into existence. The result is not only a bonkers revisionist Western, but one of our most enthralling films. The tumultuous production is delicious gossip; the rich thematic content lends itself to a variety of cultural lenses; and director Nicolas Ray’s bold colors, center framing, and stylistic idiosyncrasies are curious amenities for even a casual auteurist. But what truly holds the film together is Joan Crawford’s fierce yet vulnerable performance as Vienna.
“Crawford had been sleeping with Ray, and helped get him hired to direct Johnny Guitar with Republic Pictures, a studio known for producing low budget, but quality westerns. As detailed in the You Must Remember This podcast episode, the production was a miserable one for all involved. Crawford and Ray split up as shooting began and made life such hell for each other that Ray would often pull over on his way home to puke. Crawford was especially cruel to Mercedes McCambridge - who plays Vienna’s rival, Emma Small - reportedly throwing her costumes into the street in a drunken rage. After the film was finished Sterling Hayden, the titular Johnny Guitar, said ‘There is not enough money in Hollywood to lure me into making another picture with Joan Crawford. And I like money.’ Crawford, in turn, described Hayden as ‘the biggest pill in Hollywood.’ The film was a modest financial success, still everyone involved viewed it as a professional and artistic disaster.
“American critics mostly agreed with that assessment. But the young critics of the French New Wave were entranced. Truffaut recognized it as ‘a Western dream’ where ‘cowboys vanish and die with the grace of ballerinas.’ Johnny Guitar also lends itself easily to feminist and queer readings, with its passionate and powerful women reflecting under-represented desires and ambitions. Another layer is its function as a parable of the HUAC witch hunt. In the novel the Longergan bunch is guilty of a hold up that leads to murder. In the film (ghost written by the blacklisted Ben Maddow) they are innocent of the crime, and only hunted down because of the cowardice of townspeople too easily swayed by McCambridge’s Emma, a McCarthyesque demagogue.
“As with everything about Johnny Guitar, the characters are mythic. Johnny is a mysterious loner who comes into a new town where he falls for Vienna, the headstrong girl romantically entwined with the popular leader of a gang. A young innocent boy, Turkey, is needlessly killed. Replace Johnny with Jim, Vienna for Judy, and Turkey for Plato and you have the basic outline for Ray’s Rebel Without a Cause, released the following year. Only rather than Plato wearing Jim’s red jacket, Vienna wears Turkey’s yellow shirt.
“The story of the film unfolds like a mystery. Character details, backgrounds and actions are parceled out and often only revealed after the results of the unknown motivations have influenced the plot. That Johnny and Vienna had a past relationship is only revealed after the film’s first act. The dialog is incendiary. At times with a screwball comedy rat-a-tat: ’You’re a strange woman.’ ’Only to a stranger’; at times with poetic melodrama: ’When a fire burns itself out, all you have left is ashes’; and often with socio-political charge: ’A man can lie, steal... and even kill. But as long as he hangs on to his pride, he's still a man. All a woman has to do is slip - once. And she's a tramp!’
“In Chanslor’s book Vienna is a virgin who only meets Johnny during the course of the story. In the film she’s slept with many men, including Johnny, who is a past lover she hired for protection. The original screenplay ended with a gun fight between the men, but Crawford insisted the climax be rewritten to end with her facing off against Emma. Crawford, like Vienna, knows what she wants, and wields her power to get it.
“The film cues us into Vienna’s power from the start. She is introduced within her saloon which bears her name. In a low angle shot we see her walk onto her balcony. Her face stern but warm, she’s cognizant of every detail - down to what newspaper they are reading. She directs her roulette dealer, who we see from her God’s-eye POV, to keep the wheel spinning. ‘What for,’ he asks, gesturing at the empty saloon, ‘there are no customers.’ Her character defining response demonstrates her control over her business as well as her desires. Why should he keep the roulette wheel going with no customers? Because, she replies: ‘I like to hear it spin’.” ~ Kevin Cecil
No comments:
Post a Comment