Sunday, February 25, 2018
2017 Muriel Awards: Best Picture Addendum (The Elephant in the Room)
“It’s not a movie. Congratulations! We concede the point. Twin Peaks (subtitled The Return by Showtime but not on its subsequent video release) aired in weekly installments over the summer of 2017 just like I’m Dying Up Here, which no one in their right mind is claiming for cinema. Having established that, however, a few things need to be noted for the record. The director of all 18 hours of Twin Peaks, David Lynch, referred to the project as ‘a feature film in parts’—and while it’s true that every ambitious and/or pretentious showrunner under the sun has claimed the same, well, none of those people are David fucking Lynch. Per co-writer Mark Frost, the script was a document the size of a Manhattan phone book and encompassing the entire story, undivided into episodes. The production was shot on a feature-film schedule, with Lynch adding more material on the fly as his muse dictated. So maybe we can put it this way without causing too much controversy: Twin Peaks is an extraordinary piece of filmmaking, delivered in the form of a television series.
“The strict guidelines of the Muriel Awards prohibit those of us who would otherwise be so inclined from voting for Twin Peaks in any of the existing categories, but to ignore it altogether would be a miscarriage of justice. Let’s start with the unlikelihood of its existence at all, and the degree of difficulty involved in successfully pulling off such a belated revival. In recent memory, only Mad Max: Fury Road has managed such a feat, and even that wasn’t a direct continuation. Twin Peaks not only picked up the threads of a story that had been left dangling for more than 25 years, it brought back dozens of original cast members, most of whom didn’t miss a beat when it came to reprising their long-dormant roles.
“But Lynch and Frost had no exercise in nostalgia planned; in fact, quite the opposite. The story sprawled far beyond the borders of the quirky Pacific Northwest town fondly remembered from the original TV series, to New York, Las Vegas, South Dakota, and various bizarre planes of reality. The cast ballooned to include Lynch stalwarts like Laura Dern and Naomi Watts as well as unlikely co-conspirators ranging from Michael Cera to Jim Belushi. Through it all, however, the two central figures of the Twin Peaks saga remained the axis around which all else revolved. Kyle MacLachlan gave the performance of his career as the many aspects of Special Agent Dale Cooper, from the physical comedy and pathos of Dougie Jones to the contained fury of Mr. C to the tantalizingly brief but remarkably assured reappearance of original recipe Agent Cooper. And while Sheryl Lee’s screen time was limited, Laura Palmer continued to haunt the narrative—her absence remained the gaping hole through which all pain and suffering (garmonbozia) poured forth.
“While David Lynch would never think in such terms, Twin Peaks plays a grand career summation, incorporating obsessions and imagery from throughout his entire body of work. Absurdist humor rubs shoulders with cosmic mystery and heartrending emotion, and it all feels, well, Lynchian in the best possible way. ‘Part 8,’ with its atomic origin-of-evil pyrotechnics, has understandably garnered the most attention as perhaps the most experimental hour of television ever aired. For me, Lynch/Frost’s achievement is best summed up by the opening minutes of ‘Part 15,’ in which the soaring emotion of the long-delayed romantic reunion of Norma and Big Ed at the Double R Diner is immediately followed by the uncanny mindfuck of Agent Cooper’s evil doppelganger meeting with a former FBI agent now in the form of a giant teapot. Both of these events were equally Twin Peaks, and whether you call it a TV show, a movie, or an 18-hour interpretive dance, 2017 was far richer for having it.” ~ Scott Von Doviak
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment