Friday, February 16, 2018

2017 Muriel Awards: Best Youth Performance

I’ve been toying with this category for a few years, having first formulated the idea when doing some stage acting alongside child performers. In my experience, there’s often something different about acting as a child compared to acting as an adult. Whereas many adult performers put a lot of thought into their character’s psychology and mindset, for children (particularly younger kids) the approach tends to be less studied, more natural, sort of a game of pretend. Plus they almost invariably have their lines memorized before the adults do, which is sort of sickening the first time you notice it happen.

Anyway… Third place:


Dafne Keen - Logan [47 points / 11 votes]

Second place:


Millicent Simmonds - Wonderstruck [63 points / 14 votes]

And the winner is…


Brooklynn Prince - The Florida Project [126 points / 30 votes]

“Many great performances given by young children rely on heavy editing and stylization, fashioning a Kuleshovian facade out of their unpredictable, inexhaustible energy. This is not the case with The Florida Project's approach to Brooklynn Prince, whose energy is not only still the key to the character, and the film itself, but absolutely special in its own right. Sean Baker's interest in social structures and their effect on the people under them is here offered a challenge by a person for whom, up until a heartbreaking ending, their harmful effects have yet to fully be internalized in Prince's Moonee. The film chronicles Moonee's carefree summer in the extreme poverty dealt with by the mother and surrogate father who raise her, similarly brilliant newcomer Bria Vinaite and always brilliant Willem Dafoe. One may expect this magic to require the undeveloped perspective of a child to replicate itself in cinematic approach, but Baker and Carlos Reygadas DP Alexis Zabe work foremost in flat, static, medium length medium shots, using score only once during the fantasy end sequence. Prince riffs and rambles her way through these realist setups with supreme confidence, the camera hanging back to catalog the poverty which she has no shame of yet, only knowing the free spirit encouraged by a mother so young herself.

“Prince isn't merely playing herself either. Much more vulgar than she is in interviews, she also pushes back on authority without a hint of a fuck given, something that feels coaxed out by Baker, though credit must be given to her for embodying that rebelliousness so thoroughly. This quality could only be so keen in childhood, and in many ways the film calls on Prince to be the face of this universal early psychology before it's shed, even as this energy begins to intersect within her with her uniquely working class qualities that are thrown into sharper relief as the story continues along its tragic trajectory. In many ways, Prince must represent childhood itself, which is a common thing asked of childhood performances, but rarely is it ever placed in context, and executed, with consideration to what Nurture presages for the individual. This is some irresistible work drawn by Prince from pure acting instinct.” ~ Molly Faust

Click here for complete results.

No comments:

Post a Comment